Welcome to Hamlin Pizza Shack
Hamlin Pizza Shack, located at 1721 Lake Rd N in Hamlin, NY, is a beloved local gem known for its high-quality food and friendly service. Its casual atmosphere invites diners to relax while enjoying a diverse menu that features exceptional pizzas with perfectly crafted crusts, flavorful wings, and crowd-pleasing burgers, like the standout Cowboy burger. Customers rave about the welcoming staff and the solid value for the price. From delectable buffet nights to quick service during busy game days, this pizza shack excels in delivering satisfying meals that keep patrons coming back for more. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Hamlin Pizza Shack is a must-visit for food lovers.
Hamlin Pizza Shack: Reviews & Ratings
Been going there forever & thought I should tell why... What I like about the Hamlin Pizza Shack: good quality food, very nice people that provide great service, & the casual atmosphere. My personal favorite order: Hamburger plate, with Mac salad, beans, and EVERYTHING but mustard. Yum ;) The pizzas are really good...the crust is perfect, and did I mention? The burgers are delicious.
I have been seeing them post about buffet nights on Facebook for a while, decided to make the drive out from Medina. The food was great! And so was the service. My family loved it, the pizza was delicious and wings ! We will definitely be back!
Absolutely perfect pizza and amazing fast service on football Saturday!
This place so slept on and honestly I love that because that means there's always stuff available hahaha. BUTTTTT!!!!! I need to say my husband and I have been taking a stroll through their menu since living in Hamlin and I've got to say the Cowboy burger is by far the best thing I've had hands down!?! And I even stopped half way through the burger (for digestion lmao) for the fact I needed to make a review right now! This burger is huge!! And so filling and delicious! WOW! Go try it if you haven't!
Food is always exceptional but is a little pricey. Staff always friendly and helpful. The Atmosphere is dated and run down with that being said if you want great food this is the place to go!!!
Decor is a little dated, but still has character. Love the cheese and sauce on the pizza. Shack sauce for wings is one of a kind and a MUST TRY. Also, probably the best meat hot sauce you can find, if you like it with a kick.
Still the best pizza in Hamlin! Great crust, sauce, plenty of cheese and they don't skimp on toppings either. Delish!
We went to another pizza joint down the road with a nicer storefront/environment. Their customer service was horrible so we ended up coming to the Pizza Shack. Well we were not disappointed, we ordered a basic sheet pizza and I'll tell you it was amazing! I loved the cuomo stickers on the floor as well, great to see a local company standing up for what is right. They will have my business anytime I am in the neighborhood.
Location
-
1721 Lake Rd N, Hamlin, NY 14464, United States Hotline: +1 585-964-7170
Welcome to Hamlin Pizza Shack, a delightful gem nestled at 1721 Lake Rd N, Hamlin, NY. This quaint establishment has earned a loyal following over the years, thanks to its unwavering commitment to quality food and exceptional service.
As you step inside, you'll be greeted by a casual atmosphere that complements the warmth of the staff. Patrons rave about the inviting ambiance, perfect for families and friends alike. Rita Cannella, a long-time visitor, emphasizes how the shack’s friendly service adds to the experience, saying, "the food is good quality, and the people provide great service."
The menu is a treasure trove of options. Whether you crave a perfect slice of pizza or a juicy burger, Hamlin Pizza Shack has you covered. Their pizza is known for its flawless crust, making it a favorite among locals. Daniel Mawn notes, "Absolutely perfect pizza and amazing fast service," especially during those spirited football Saturdays.
Don't overlook their acclaimed burgers, particularly the Cowboy Burger, as highlighted by Taylor Dibley. She describes it as "huge!! And so filling and delicious!" Each bite is a celebration of flavor that keeps patrons coming back for more.
For those looking for variety, Hamlin Pizza Shack also hosts buffet nights, a hit among families like that of Randy Wyant, who traveled from Medina just to indulge. With a range of pizzas and wings on offer, it’s a perfect opportunity to taste a little bit of everything.
While some customers note that the atmosphere is dated, the exceptional food makes it worth the visit. Kristopher Schwarzott affirms that the delicious food makes up for any faults in decor, saying, "this is the place to go for great food!"
If you're in the Hamlin area or just passing through, Hamlin Pizza Shack is a must-try. With its blend of quality, friendly service, and a menu that pleases every palate, a visit here promises to be rewarding. Why not drop by and taste the magic for yourself?
For inquiries, give them a call at +1 585-964-7170. Your next culinary adventure awaits!